Bad Nights at ‘The Libertine’
- Handel’s ‘Messiah’: A Celebration by Richard Luckett
Gollancz, 258 pp, £18.99, April 1992, ISBN 0 575 05286 4
- The Rise of Musical Classics in 18th-Century England: A Study in Canon, Ritual and Ideology by William Weber
Oxford, 274 pp, £35.00, July 1992, ISBN 0 19 816287 1
Kwabena Nketia tells us, in his book African Music, that ‘music’ is defined in Africa through the social uses to which it is put. Some native African languages don’t have a word for music as a thing in itself (which, of course, it isn’t, looked at socially), but instead have different words for cradle-rocking-to-sounds, pounding-maize-to-sounds, music-for-hunting-to and so forth. But is there such a thing, anyway, as ‘music: a system of organised sounds which give pleasure, and obey’ – ‘obeying’ may include ‘flouting’ – ‘the conventions of its grammar’? The organisation of pop music is imperceptible to me, its grammar foreign, and its pleasures non-existent. I readily concede that this is not the experience of everyone. The phenomenon is widely-known, but doesn’t get much noticed. A woman I was talking to at a party recently thought that I was playing a complicated sort of game and simply could not believe me when I said I had never heard of, let alone heard, the particular rock group all her children were listening to.
The full text of this book review is only available to subscribers of the London Review of Books.