Family Romances

Anthony Thwaite

  • A Little Stranger by Candia McWilliam
    Bloomsbury, 135 pp, £12.95, January 1989, ISBN 0 7475 0279 X
  • Running wild by J.G. Ballard
    Hutchinson, 72 pp, £5.95, November 1988, ISBN 0 09 173498 3
  • Breathing Lessons by Anne Tyler
    Chatto, 327 pp, £11.95, January 1989, ISBN 0 7011 3391 0

Candia McWilliam’s first novel, A Case of Knives, won the Betty Trask Award last year. I expect I am wrong in persistently remembering this as a prize for something called Romantic Fiction; I believe I am right in thinking that the rubric was extended to include the words ‘or traditional’. The formidable young McWilliam doesn’t seem to me to fit comfortably under either label. A Case of Knives was a dazzling, burnished, stilt-walking stylistic exercise, like that of a very clever student who had been nourished on a forced diet of John Cleveland, George Barker (The Dead Seagull) and Craig Raine, and who had once heard the plot of a novel by Iris Murdoch. The novel’s characters were indeed Romantic, if by that one means fabulous, fanciful, whimsical, high-flown, etc, as under Roget 515: Lucas Salik, Anne Cowdenbeath, Cora Godfrey and the rest seemed precocious fictions, made palpable only by the finely-honed language in which they expressed themselves (‘Language is a case of knives’): ‘I was driven home by a man with no hands, my heart belonging to a man who was a mender of hearts, and within me was growing another heart, not mine at all, but never quite not mine. These grotesque anatomical tmeses touched my dreams through a thin sleep.’ Grotesque tmeses appeared to be what Candia McWilliam was good at.

The full text of this book review is only available to subscribers of the London Review of Books.

You are not logged in