Diary

W.G. Runciman: Like a Prep School, 10 January 1991

“... The publisher’s launching party for David Cannadine’s Decline and Fall of the British Aristocracy in the Moses Room of the House of Lords on 22 October was the third occasion on which I had been inside that curious place since taking my seat as a hereditary member of it. The Moses Room is evidently so called because its walls depict, in tableaux more impressive for their size than their quality, the appropriate Old Testament scenes ...”

Who won the Falklands War?

Edward Luttwak, 23 April 1992

One Hundred Days: The Memoirs of the Falklands Battle Group Commander 
byAdmiral Sandy Woodward and Patrick Robinson.
HarperCollins, 359 pp., £18, January 1992, 0 00 215723 3
Show More
Show More
“... Falklands would almost certainly have failed, thereby ensuring that Argentina would still today be ruled by a triumphalist military élite, inept mismanagers of a decaying economy, impotent spectators of the country’s social disintegration, and of course both cruel and corrupt. As it is, defeated Argentina is undergoing ...”

Incandescences

Richard Poirier, 20 December 1979

The Powers that Be 
byDavid Halberstam.
Chatto, 771 pp., £9.95
Show More
Show More
“... This book, by a man who at 35 was already called ‘a legend in American journalism’, is a lengthy and anecdotal analysis of the transactions between political power in the United States during the last fifty years and the power of the mass media. The latter are exemplified for Halberstam by four conglomerates of the American communications industry, each more or less in the control of a single family: the Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS), created and run by William Paley; Time Inc, including Life, owned by Henry Luce; the Washington Post and Newsweek, run by Philip and then by Kay Graham; and the Chandler family’s Los Angeles Times ...”

Walter Scott’s Post-War Europe

Marilyn Butler, 7 February 1980

Walter Scott and the Historical Imagination 
byDavid Brown.
Routledge, 239 pp., £9.75, August 1980, 0 7100 0301 3
Show More
Show More
“... process, the first portrayer of society in terms that Adam Smith might and Karl Marx did approve. David Brown makes the academic case admirably. He begins by modestly disclaiming originality: he is developing insights put forward by others in recent years, and only applying them more ...”

Utility

Richard Tuck, 16 July 1981

Social Justice in the Liberal State 
byBruce Ackerman.
Yale, 392 pp., £11, October 1980, 0 300 02439 8
Show More
Justice and Liberty 
byDavid Raphael.
Athlone, 192 pp., £13, November 1980, 0 485 11195 0
Show More
Show More
“... The refutation of utilitarianism, and its replacement by some new and comprehensive alternative, has become one of the major Anglo-American growth industries. The problem of how to live with a liberal and mildly interventionist state if we no longer accept the premisses upon which such a state was originally founded has rightly exercised philosophers on both sides of the Atlantic, though it is striking how difficult it has proved for them fully to disentangle themselves from the old ways of thinking ...”

North and South

Linda Colley, 2 August 2012

“... nation state in the way post-Revolutionary France often tried to do. This does not mean the UK can be regarded merely as a multinational state, or (pace some post-colonialist commentators) as an English-constructed empire. Instead, the UK has most closely resembled what the Columbia political scientist Alfred Stepan styles a ‘state-nation’. Like many other ...”

The NHS Dismantled

John Furse, 7 November 2019

“... on hospitals. Health Maintenance Organisations (HMOs), the forerunners of ACOs, were pioneered by the US health insurance provider Kaiser Permanente in 1953. President Nixon’s adviser John Ehrlichman explained to his boss the basic concept before the passage of the 1973 HMO Act: ‘The less care they give them the more money they make.’ In May 2016 ...”

Short Cuts

Jonathan Parry: Harry Goes Rogue, 6 February 2020

“... most polls done over the last fifty years) of its representativeness. This representativeness can be defined in two broad ways. One is constitutional. The monarchy survived the critiques of 19th-century radicals not because of any political skill of its own but because the state – of which it was the leading symbol – purified and liberalised itself ...”

At the Pompidou

Jeremy Harding: David Goldblatt, 26 April 2018

“... African labour market,’ Charles van Onselen writes in New Nineveh, ‘has always been dominated by … mining, agriculture and domestic service.’ Van Onselen’s two-volume history of ‘everyday life in the Witwatersrand’, a long ridge on the Highveld, explores the period from the mid-1880s when the discovery of gold propelled South Africa through a ...”

Pugin’s Law

Mark Swenarton, 4 December 1980

The Work of Sir Gilbert Scott 
byDavid Cole.
Architectural Press, 244 pp., £25, May 1980, 0 85139 723 9
Show More
Lutyens Country Houses 
byDaniel O’Neill.
Lund Humphries, 167 pp., £8.95, May 1980, 0 85331 428 4
Show More
A Revolution in London Housing: LCC Housing Architects and their Work 1893-1914 
bySusan Beattic.
GLC/Architectural Press, 127 pp., £6.95, July 1980, 0 85139 560 0
Show More
Show More
“... of the 19th and 20th centuries, the authors deal, not with the global issues envisaged by Pugin but with the careers of famous (and, in one case, not-so-famous) architects. The history of architecture, we are asked to believe, is the history of the individuals whose names appeared on architectural drawings. The justification for this biographical ...”

Point of Principle

Michael Irwin, 2 April 1981

The Country 
byDavid Plante.
Gollancz, 159 pp., £6.95, March 1981, 0 575 02938 2
Show More
The Radiant Future 
byAlexander Zinoviev, translated byGordon Clough.
Bodley Head, 287 pp., £7.50, March 1981, 0 370 30219 2
Show More
Farewell to Europe 
byWalter Laqueur.
Weidenfeld, 310 pp., £6.50, March 1981, 0 297 77870 6
Show More
Show More
“... adroitly restricted to an account of four visits. The first two, at intervals of a year, are paid by Daniel Francoeur, an American writer long resident in London, to his aging parents in Rhode Island. He finds them unhappy, constrained by repressed hostility and old disappointments. His mother, now an invalid who confines ...”

Looking back

Hugh Thomas, 7 July 1983

The Spanish Civil War 
byDavid Mitchell.
Granada, 208 pp., £9.95, December 1982, 0 246 11916 0
Show More
Show More
“... no worse than the old-fashioned Catholic Right: perhaps better, if the fate of Garcia Lorca be considered, for he was safe when being looked after in the house of fascists, and betrayed to his death by a Catholic ex-deputy. The Republic certainly did retain the services of men of integrity, to the end, but the shadow ...”

Diary

A.J.P. Taylor: On Not Being Egocentric Enough, 4 August 1983

“... just go on parading their mutual distrust until it has become a way of life, and neither side will be satisfied until it has provoked a world explosion. I humbly think this is a mistake, but there is no limit to the extent of human folly. As to Hungary, it had an obscurantist regime in the days of Regent Horthy and it was a great stroke for Hungary when the ...”

So far so Bletchley Park

John Ray, 8 June 1995

Deciphering the Indus Script 
byAsko Parpola.
Cambridge, 374 pp., £60, September 1994, 0 521 43079 8
Show More
The World on Paper 
byDavid Olson.
Cambridge, 318 pp., £17.95, May 1994, 0 521 44311 3
Show More
Show More
“... The earliest examples come from southern Mesopotamia, and date to the end of the fourth millennium BC. They were used to record economic transactions, and there remained a distinctly mercantile quality to Mesopotamian civilisation throughout its history. Egypt soon followed, with similar ideas but with differing emphasis, since Egyptian writing seems to have ...”

Deep Down in the Trash

Robert Crawford, 21 August 1997

God’s Gift to Women 
byDon Paterson.
Faber, 64 pp., £6.99, May 1997, 9780571177622
Show More
Show More
“... Younger Scottish writers seem to be preoccupied by gender. It is a theme crucial equally to Duncan McLean’s novel Bunker Man and to Kathleen Jamie’s poetry collection The Queen of Sheba. It is insistent in W.N. Herbert’s poem ‘Featherhood’ and Janice Galloway’s Foreign Parts ...”