Mad or bad?
Michael Ignatieff, 18 June 1981
Trial by Medicine: Insanity and Responsibility in Victorian Trials
by Roger Smith.
Edinburgh, 288 pp., £15, March 1981,9780852244074 Show More
by Roger Smith.
Edinburgh, 288 pp., £15, March 1981,
“... impulse’ and ‘moral insanity’ had allowed the would-be assassin of Queen Victoria, Edward Oxford, to escape the gallows three years previously. The doctors, for their part, criticised the M’Naghten Rules for failing to take any account of the unconscious. What, they asked, was the law to do with murderers who were rational, conscious of ... ”