- The Letters of D.H. Lawrence, Vol II: June 1913-October 1916 edited by George Zytaruk and James Boulton
Cambridge, 700 pp, £20.00, May 1982, ISBN 0 521 23111 6
- Selected Short Stories by D.H. Lawrence, edited by Brian Finney
Penguin, 540 pp, £1.95, June 1982, ISBN 0 13 043160 5
- The Trespasser by D.H. Lawrence, edited by Elizabeth Mansfield
Cambridge, 327 pp, £22.50, April 1982, ISBN 0 521 22264 8
These are the years of early fame after Sons and Lovers, and of the publication of The Rainbow and its banning, and of Lawrence’s violent and despairing reactions to the war. He was already a fully recognised writer, a probable genius, and his more intimate correspondents include Cynthia Asquith, Ottoline Morrell, Bertrand Russell, Edward Marsh, Middleton Murry and Katherine Mansfield, Philip Heseltine, Mark Gertler. The letters to Russell tell a particularly vivid story. Lawrence harassed Russell relentlessly and at great length, repetitiously and in a wilfully unpleasant tone. He kept on banging away at Russell’s vaunted rationality, his putative concern with peace, his humanitarian sentiments. ‘What you want is to jab and strike, like the soldier with the bayonet, only you are sublimated into words... It is not the hatred of falsehood which inspires you. It is the hatred of people, of flesh and blood.’ Russell endured more, and for a longer time, than his autobiography suggested. His forbearance was astonishing, and it must be interpreted as coming from the respect that Russell believed to be owed to genius. He must have found it tiresome to be told in letter after letter that his pacifism was a cloak for his natural aggressiveness, and that his concern for humanity disguised a cold detachment: particularly tiresome, because the accusations probably had some measure of truth, a nagging plausibility, at least. It is not surprising that he sought a respite and that the friendship finally foundered.
The full text of this book review is only available to subscribers of the London Review of Books.