Fiction and the Poverty of Theory

John Sutherland, 20 November 1986

News from Nowhere 
byDavid Caute.
Hamish Hamilton, 403 pp., £10.95, September 1986, 0 241 11920 0
Show More
O-Zone 
byPaul Theroux.
Hamish Hamilton, 469 pp., £9.95, October 1986, 0 241 11948 0
Show More
Ticket to Ride 
byDennis Potter.
Faber, 202 pp., £9.95, September 1986, 9780571145232
Show More
Show More
“... A drunken American historian once lurched over to David Caute at a party and told him: ‘Having read your last novel, or part of it, I’d advise you to give up writing fiction – if you weren’t such a lousy historian.’ Caute, a connoisseur of masochism, tells the story against himself (in Contemporary Novelists, 1976 ...”

Bobbing Along

Ronald Stevens: The Press Complaints Commission, 7 February 2002

A Press Free and Responsible: Self-Regulation and the Press Complaints Commission 1991-2001 
byRichard Shannon.
Murray, 392 pp., £25, September 2001, 0 7195 6321 6
Show More
Show More
“... against the customer while pretending to do the reverse. For an industry which is supposed to be alert and quick on its feet, the press took a long time to appreciate the advantages of having a watchdog of its own with india-rubber teeth. A General Council of the Press was recommended in 1949 by the first postwar Royal ...”

At the National Portrait Gallery

Andrew O’Hagan: Lucian Freud, 26 April 2012

“... Titian’s Diana and Actaeon and Diana and Callisto were described by Lucian Freud as ‘simply the most beautiful pictures in the world’. And not long ago, in an act of Alex Salmond-defying co-operation, the National Gallery of Scotland and the National Gallery of Great Britain raided their respective coffers – as well as the coffers of their respective, culturally estranged governments – to buy the pictures from the Duke of Sutherland ...”

Short Cuts

Norman Dombey: False Intelligence, 19 February 2004

“... Fifteen months ago in these pages I reviewed a book by Khidhir Hamza, who called himself ‘Saddam’s bombmaker’. At the same time I assessed the now notorious government dossier of September 2002 on Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction, together with the more restrained document published by the International Institute of Strategic Studies ...”

Marching Orders

Ronan Bennett: The new future of Northern Ireland, 30 July 1998

“... Rule for Ireland and of any showdown between the British Government and the Ulster Unionists, but by the end of the war the popular mood in Ireland, stirred by trauma of Easter Week 1916, was overwhelmingly in favour of some form of independence: Sinn Fein won 73 of 105 seats in the General Election of 1918, the last held ...”

So Ordinary, So Glamorous

Thomas Jones: Eternal Bowie, 5 April 2012

Starman: David Bowie, the Definitive Biography 
byPaul Trynka.
Sphere, 440 pp., £9.99, March 2012, 978 0 7515 4293 6
Show More
The Man Who Sold the World: David Bowie and the 1970s 
byPeter Doggett.
Bodley Head, 424 pp., £20, September 2011, 978 1 84792 144 4
Show More
Show More
“... a monument to improbable staying power. It’s more than two decades since Moss was photographed by Corinne Day for the Face, those instantly iconic black and white images of a skinny 16-year-old on Camber Sands, wearing no make-up and very few clothes, grinning through her freckles and pointy teeth, all at once so English, so ordinary and so glamorous. And ...”

It’s as if he’d never existed

Anthony Pagden, 18 July 1985

The Transformation of Spain: From Franco to the Constitutional Monarchy 
byDavid Gilmour.
Quartet, 306 pp., £12.95, March 1985, 9780704324619
Show More
Show More
“... Le Canard Enchaîné, went as follows: the young prince Felipe asks the king, whether there will be a public holiday when Franco dies. Yes, he replies. And, papa, will there be a holiday when you are declared king? Yes, says the king. And, papa, will there be a holiday when the Republic ...”

Funny Old Fame

Patrick Parrinder, 10 January 1991

Things: A Story of the Sixties, 
byGeorges Perec, translated byDavid Bellos and Andrew Leak.
Collins Harvill, 221 pp., £12.50, July 1990, 0 00 271038 2
Show More
Parcours Peree 
edited byMireille Ribière.
Presses Universitaires de Lyon, 162 pp., frs 125, July 1990, 2 7297 0365 9
Show More
Women 
byPhilippe Sollers, translated byBarbara Bray.
Columbia, 559 pp., $24.95, December 1990, 0 231 06546 9
Show More
Show More
“... last years of Mrs Thatcher’s reign it was Perec, not Sollers, who – with the publication of David Bellos’s translation of Life: A User’s Manual – found a keen British audience. There were logics in these things, as we shall see. Perec’s reputation might easily have crossed the Channel two decades earlier. His first novel, Les Choses, was ...”

Shakers

Denis Donoghue, 6 November 1986

Write on: Occasional Essays ’65-’85 
byDavid Lodge.
Secker, 211 pp., £12.95, September 1986, 0 436 25665 7
Show More
Show More
“... This is a gathering of David Lodge’s easy pieces: they are footnotes, shouldernotes and headnotes to the formal work in fiction and literary criticism he has published in the past twenty years. The book is in two parts. The first, ‘Personal and Descriptive’, includes a memoir of his first year in America, mostly a travel-year, 1964-65; his report on the turbulence at Berkeley in 1969; a trip to Poland in 1981; memories of a Catholic childhood; how he came to read Joyce; an introduction to his novel Small World; and his account of going to a Shakin’ Stevens concert in Birmingham ...”

Doing the impossible

James Joll, 7 May 1981

Retreat from Power: Studies in Britain’s Foreign Policy of the 20th Century 
edited byDavid Dilks.
Macmillan, 213 pp., £10, February 1981, 0 333 28910 2
Show More
Show More
“... power from disturbing it. In the 1980s, the foreign policy of every country is conditioned by the state of the nuclear balance of power, and Britain, like other small states, has very little opportunity to conduct an independent foreign policy on a world scale. British foreign policy today is ineluctably shaped ...”

Fatalism

Graham Hough, 16 July 1981

A Start in Life 
byAnita Brookner.
Cape, 176 pp., £5.95, May 1981, 9780224018999
Show More
Rhine Journey 
byAnn Schlee.
Macmillan, 165 pp., £5.95, March 1981, 0 333 28320 1
Show More
The Sure Salvation 
byJohn Hearne.
Faber, 224 pp., £6.50, May 1981, 0 571 11670 1
Show More
Beloved Latitudes 
byDavid Pownall.
Gollancz, 140 pp., £6.95, May 1981, 0 575 02988 9
Show More
Show More
“... fatalist acceptance: but the spheres of their sorrow are divided on strictly traditional lines by the gender of their authors – the cannon and the firing-squad against the drawing-room and the kitchen stove. At the end of David Pownall’s book the protagonist and his confidant are shot. At the end of John Hearne’s ...”

Everything bar the Chopsticks

T.H. Barrett, 30 October 1997

The City of Light 
byJacob d’Ancona, translated and edited byDavid Selbourne.
Little, Brown, 392 pp., £22.50, October 1997, 0 316 63968 0
Show More
Show More
“... phrase corresponding exactly to our ‘terra incognita’, a label unknown to Chinese cartography. David Selbourne was probably unaware of these fakes when he embarked on his translation of the text he now entitles The City of Light, but it is worth pointing them out, just to make clear that the notion that Italian manuscripts concerning medieval Asian travel ...”

Speaking Azza

Martin Jay: Where are you coming from?, 28 November 2002

Situatedness; Or, Why We Keep Saying Where We’re Coming From 
byDavid Simpson.
Duke, 290 pp., £14.50, March 2002, 0 8223 2839 9
Show More
Show More
“... As a colleague of David Simpson at the University of California and a friend graciously thanked in his acknowledgments, can I pretend to have the disinterestedness necessary to write an objective review of his book? Or, as a reviewer opening with a confession of this sort – what in the lingo of our day is called a ‘full disclosure’ – have I then somehow neutralised my personal stake in such a way that I can offer my opinion as unbiased? Can such reflexivity work to undo the debilitating effects of situatedness? These are the kinds of question that agonise Simpson, who has written Situatedness in the hope of stemming the tide of what he calls, following Andrew Sullivan, ‘azza’ declarations – ‘as a colleague of David Simpson’; ‘as a white, middle-class male’ – in the age of identity politics ...”

A Plumless Pudding

John Sutherland: The Great John Murray Archive Disaster, 18 March 2004

“... because those that don’t go out of business. Backlists and post-mortem copyright dispose them to be historically minded about their dealings. It was only relatively recently, however, that libraries and other storehouses of scholarship first became aware of the cultural, literary, historical and scientific value of the intact publisher’s ...”

Ante Antietam

Michael Irwin, 24 January 1980

Confederates 
byThomas Keneally.
Collins, 427 pp., £5.75, October 1980, 0 00 222141 1
Show More
Just Above My Head 
byJames Baldwin.
Joseph, 597 pp., £6.95, October 1980, 0 7181 1764 6
Show More
Winter Doves 
byDavid Cook.
Secker, 213 pp., £4.95, October 1980, 0 436 10673 6
Show More
All Girls Together 
byPaula Neuss.
Duckworth, 141 pp., £5.95, November 1980, 0 7156 1454 1
Show More
Show More
“... risks. The potential subject-matter is dauntingly multifarious. How could so vast a tragedy be focused and individualised? It was a war that fairly compels the commentator to take sides. Can the novelist do so without telling a one-sided story? Above all, could any outsider – Thomas Keneally is Australian – hope to capture the atmosphere, the ...”