Nude Horses
Jerrold Seigel, 3 April 1997
The Plight of Emulation: Ernest Meissonier and French Salon Painting
by Marc Gotlieb.
Princeton, 264 pp., £33.50, May 1996,0 691 04374 4 Show More
by Marc Gotlieb.
Princeton, 264 pp., £33.50, May 1996,
“... on such slim evidence. At one point Gotlieb contrasts Meissonier’s supposed flight from ‘the self-referentiality that defines the history of Western painting’ to Manet’s attempt to ‘thematise’ modern art’s relationship to tradition ‘in his major canvasses of the 1860s’. It’s a promising comparison, but Gotlieb’s way of proposing it ... ”