The Real Magic
David Sylvester, 8 June 1995
A Biographical Dictionary of Film
by David Thomson.
Deutsch, 834 pp., £25, November 1994,0 233 98859 9 Show More
by David Thomson.
Deutsch, 834 pp., £25, November 1994,
“... but how many musicals are great films? Or, speaking of moments, the killing of Jack Palance by Alan Ladd in Shane is exquisite, but Shane as a whole is a phoney. (But its director, George Stevens, did direct a musical that’s a serious candidate for greatness: Swing Time.) And the problem of evaluating the makers is vastly complicated, as it is with the ... ”