The Earnestness of Being Important

P.N. Furbank, 19 August 1982

John Buchan: A Memoir 
byWilliam Buchan.
Buchan and Enright, 272 pp., £9.95, May 1982, 0 907675 03 4
Show More
The Best Short Stories of John Buchan. Vol. II 
edited byDavid Daniell.
Joseph, 240 pp., £8.50, June 1982, 9780718121211
Show More
Show More
“... upon Britain. One’s sense of Buchan the man, as derived from the excellent and engaging memoir by his son William, is of someone vastly enjoying life. How else could anyone have done so much and covered so much paper – more than a million words in Nelson’s History of the War alone? But then the consciousness of giving pleasure on such a scale (and it ...”

Diary

Ian Hamilton: It's a size thing, 19 September 1985

“... He felt that we (I myself was one of the ‘wimp’ critics he objected to) had been made nervous by his powerful masculinity and, to cover up our fear, we had tried to get macho with his book. Mailer was angry, says The Face, and he was spoiling for a fight. What is it with these New York lit-celebs? A year or two ago, Gore Vidal published a book-length ...”

Censorship

John Bayley, 7 August 1986

No, I’m not afraid 
byIrina Ratushinskaya, translated byDavid McDuff.
Bloodaxe, 142 pp., £4.95, May 1986, 0 906427 95 9
Show More
Shcharansky: Hero of Our Time 
byMartin Gilbert.
Macmillan, 467 pp., £14.95, April 1986, 0 333 39504 2
Show More
The Russian Orthodox Church: A Contemporary History 
byJane Ellis.
Croom Helm, 531 pp., £27.50, April 1986, 0 7099 1567 5
Show More
Show More
“... people, was not at all opposed to the censorship of his time. ‘Let us have a strict censorship by all means, but not a senseless one,’ he writes to a friend, as if strictness (strogost) were a cosy and reassuring fact of Russian life, as it might be in England village cricket or well-rolled umbrellas. How else explain ...”

What Nanny Didn’t Tell Me

Bernard Porter: Simon Mann, 26 January 2012

Cry Havoc 
bySimon Mann.
John Blake, 351 pp., £19.99, November 2011, 978 1 84358 403 2
Show More
Show More
“... Guinea thinly disguised – and replace its tyrannical president with one who will, perhaps, be less tyrannical, and will definitely grant Sir James the highly profitable platinum-mining concession he wants. The operation goes like clockwork – no problems, no mistakes – though there’s a twist at the end. Simon Mann’s Cry Havoc might seem like a ...”

Like Frogs around a Pond

Nigel McGilchrist: The Mediterranean, 22 March 2012

The Great Sea: A Human History of the Mediterranean 
byDavid Abulafia.
Allen Lane, 783 pp., £30, May 2011, 978 0 7139 9934 1
Show More
Show More
“... The title of David Abulafia’s magisterial book comes, as he reminds us, from a Hebrew blessing, to be recited when setting eyes on the Mediterranean: ‘Blessed are you, Lord our God, king of the Universe, who made the Great Sea.’ His book is a two-fold history: first of the trade and the traders who discovered the sea, created its ports and never ceased thereafter to animate it in pursuit of commerce ...”

Venice-on-Thames

Amanda Vickery: Vauxhall Gardens, 7 February 2013

Vauxhall Gardens: A History 
byAlan Borg and David Coke.
Yale, 473 pp., £55, June 2011, 978 0 300 17382 6
Show More
Show More
“... of a ticket, one could enjoy musical performances and refreshments al fresco, or simply see and be seen. Princes rubbed shoulders with prostitutes, duchesses with doctors’ daughters: the social mix was a large part of the gardens’ attraction at the time and our fascination with them now. They seem to have epitomised the comparative openness of a polite ...”

Mindblind

Ian Hacking: Religion’s evolutionary origins, 21 October 2004

In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion 
byScott Atran.
Oxford, 348 pp., £20.99, November 2002, 0 19 514930 0
Show More
Show More
“... rationalist atheist. Atran calls himself agnostic, but no matter. Certainly, no form of theism, be it mono, poly or pan, is on the cards as a live possibility in this book: the beliefs are implausible and the practices are demanding. Atran gives endless examples from anthropology, but we need go no further than the Anglican creed. It speaks of a man ...”

I saw them in my visage

Michael Dobson: Shakespeare and Race, 6 February 2025

White People in Shakespeare: Essays in Race, Culture and the Elite 
edited byArthur Little.
Bloomsbury, 320 pp., £21.99, January 2023, 978 1 350 28566 8
Show More
Shakespeare’s White Others 
byDavid Sterling Brown.
Cambridge, 214 pp., £30, August 2023, 978 1 009 38416 2
Show More
The Great White Bard: How to Love Shakespeare while Talking about Race 
byFarah Karim-Cooper.
Oneworld, 328 pp., £11.99, April 2024, 978 0 86154 809 5
Show More
Show More
“... ball, fleetingly registers the contrast between her torchlit beauty and the surrounding darkness by imagining a jewel sparkling in the earlobe of a nameless African? For the scholars in this important group of critical studies, his aside serves principally as evidence of an emergent racialised system visible throughout Elizabethan culture. Night is ...”

Diary

Andrew O’Hagan: Whitney lives!, 8 May 2025

“... the eve​ of the first lockdown, I made my way to the Hammersmith Apollo to attend a performance by Whitney Houston. It was a chill, ominous night and the people outside the venue were wide-eyed and excited about their forthcoming encounter with the undead. I had come along in the course of my duties as a hopeless necromantic. I don’t think I have ever ...”

The New Phrenology

Patrick Wall, 17 December 1981

Mind in Science 
byRichard Gregory.
Weidenfeld, 641 pp., £18.50, September 1981, 0 297 77825 0
Show More
Show More
“... men honoured for their contribution to our knowledge of the brain: Roger Sperry from Cal Tech and David Hubel and Torsten Wiesel from Harvard. Their discoveries are stunning, counter-intuitive and of no immediate practical consequence. They are therefore widely unknown outside their fraternity. A further reason for their obscurity is that the hard facts they ...”

Grounds for Despair

John Dunn, 17 September 1981

After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory 
byAlasdair MacIntyre.
Duckworth, 252 pp., £24, July 1981, 0 7156 0933 5
Show More
Show More
“... of the character traits which she looks for in a prospective husband. ‘I would require him to be free in all his thoughts, true in all his words, generous in all his actions – ardent in friendship, enthusiastic in love, disinterested in both … the champion of the feeble, the firm opponent of the powerful oppressor – not to ...”

Picking the winner

Keith Kyle, 7 July 1983

Tom Mboya: The Man Kenya Wanted to Forget 
byDavid Goldsworthy.
Heinemann/Africana, 308 pp., £13, June 1982, 0 435 96275 2
Show More
Show More
“... of Nairobi. How long would Mzee – Jomo Kenyatta, ‘The Old Man’ – last? And what was to be done about Tom Mboya? Kenya had emerged from the anti-colonial struggle with two leaders of world renown, one young, dynamic and immensely talented, the other old (no one was quite sure how old) and respected as much for what he had suffered as for what he had ...”

The Vicar of Chippenham

Christopher Haigh: Religion and the life-cycle, 15 October 1998

Birth, Marriage and Death: Ritual, Religion and the Life-Cycle in Tudor and Stuart England 
byDavid Cressy.
Oxford, 641 pp., £25, May 1998, 0 19 820168 0
Show More
Show More
“... or a wake. For the clergy, however, ritual is a serious business. They want their ceremonies to be tidy, dignified and meaningful – no photographs in church, no confetti in the churchyard. They prefer not to christen the babies of non-churchgoers, nor to heap hypocrisies on the coffins of people they have never known. This conflict of priorities is not a ...”

Why Christ is playing with the Magdalene’s Hair

Nicholas Penny: Correggio, 2 July 1998

Correggio 
byDavid Ekserdjian.
Yale, 334 pp., £45, January 1997, 0 300 07299 6
Show More
The ‘Divine’ Guido 
byRichard Spear.
Yale, 436 pp., £40, January 1997, 0 300 07035 7
Show More
Show More
“... In the centre of the most beautiful painting by Correggio in the Louvre there is a knot of flesh as intricate and lively as a swimming octopus. It consists of the left hand of the Virgin Mary delicately supporting the slightly smaller right hand of Saint Catharine, while the much smaller hand of the infant Christ tenderly picks out the Saint’s ring finger ...”

Following the Fall-Out

Alexander Star: Rick Moody, 19 March 1998

Purple America 
byRick Moody.
Flamingo, 298 pp., £16.99, March 1998, 0 00 225687 8
Show More
Show More
“... When the logic of crisis is put in motion, the outlook further darkens. In Moody’s novels, to be born is a crime, and to grow up compounds the offence. The enclosed residences of American affluence are under a curse – nature and neuroses will contrive to bring them low. Moody delivers this dark verdict in a casual, off-hand prose. His miniature family ...”