Rubbing Up

• Growing Up by Russell Baker
  Sidgwick, 278 pp, £9.95, February 1984, ISBN 0 283 99056 2
• Scouse Mouse, or I never got over it: An Autobiography by George Melly
  Weidenfeld, 208 pp, £8.95, March 1984, ISBN 0 297 78277 0
• The Haunted Mind by Hallam Tennyson
  Deutsch, 238 pp, £12.95, May 1984, ISBN 0 333 97618 5

Born within months of each other, both raised under constant scrutiny by powerful grandparents, both made into vehicles for their mothers’ repressed artistic ambitions: the early histories of George Melly and Russell Baker run strikingly in parallel. Their books reveal an even more striking coincidence of form. Melly chooses, in his closing paragraph, to play affectionately along with his mother’s happy delusion that she is fifty years back in the past and the conjuror is coming to tea. Baker begins and ends his story with a baroque variation on exactly the same theme. Senility, that affliction so often viewed with embarrassed horror, is seen by Baker as yet another manifestation of his mother’s courageous resourcefulness – she turned herself into her own time-machine.