« | Home | »

Organic doesn’t mean healthy


Don’t think that because your salad sprouts are organic, grown on your window sill, and supposedly good for you, that they haven’t accumulated many food miles or are safe to eat raw. Compelling evidence published by the European Food Safety Authority yesterday points to fenugreek sprouts as the vector of the E. coli that caused the enormous German outbreak in May and June (more than 3000 cases, with 47 deaths) and a French outbreak at Bègles, near Bordeaux, in June. The only common factors in the outbreaks were genetically identical E. coli O104:H4 – and fenugreek from the same Egyptian source.

Fifteen thousand kilogrammes of organic fenugreek seeds, lot number 48088 (expiry date November 2011), left Egypt by sea in November 2009 in a sealed container. Offloaded at Antwerp, it went to Rotterdam by barge and travelled by road to a German distributor, arriving on 15 December. In February this year, 75 kg went to the sprout producer linked to the German outbreak. Four hundred kilogrammes went to a British seed supplier who in January this year sold 95 kg in 50g packets to a French distributor, who in turn supplied batches of between 5 and 125 packets to more than 200 outlets. Seeds from one packet were sprouted in a jam jar and eaten at an open day at a children’s community centre in Bègles on 8 June. The sprouts went into cold carrot and cumin and courgette soups, and on crudités.

E. coli O104:H4 is very virulent. Many victims have developed haemolytic uraemic syndrome (which causes kidney failure) and brain damage. A much greater proportion of the infected have developed these complications than is usual with the classical nasty E. coli, O157. It is quite likely that O104 is hot because it is a hybrid. It has the toxins that make O157 virulent coupled with many genes from enteroaggregative E. coli, a bacterium thought to be a common cause of diarrhoea in children in developing countries. Night soil on the fenugreek?

Comments on “Organic doesn’t mean healthy”

  1. Earlier today I posted a comment which suggested the original title to this piece ‘Don’t eat organic’ represented a premature conclusion that organic food per se was in some way to blame for the E coli problems that Hugh Pennington outlines. Later, the title was changed and my comment was deleted. Yet the new title again makes a generic comment about organic food that is not justified by the evidence.

    Most of Hugh’s blog is a fair reflection of the recently published EFSA report, which does identify that the most likely source of the serious E coli problems in Germany and France is a consignment of organic fenugreek seed from Egypt. But the following points are relevant whatever the title given to this piece:

    1. The EFSA report confirms that no contaminated seed has yet been found, and the contamination could have taken place at any point in the chain up to when it left the importer’s warehouse.

    2. Under the EU organic regulations, which also apply to imports, organic producers are prohibited from using sewage sludge or other forms of human faeces (including night soil). The same restrictions do not apply to non-organic producers, so, if the contamintion happened on the farm, the problem described would be more likely to occur on a non-organic holding. If it happened on an organic holding, then this would have been either accidental or a regulatory infringement, not a typical organic farming practice.

    3. In reality, this is a serious food safety issue that could have affected any food producer, whether organic or not. While the investigators are continuing to look for the real source of the problem, not just the vector, it is inappropriate to attribute blame to a particular sector – far too much economic damage has been done to innocent producers already in this way.

    In a serious forum like this, one would hope that the need not just for robust evidence, but also for coherent identification of cause and effect relationships, would be recognised. It seems that there is still some way to go on this.

  2. Geoff Roberts says:

    ‘Organic’ doesn’t mean ‘healthy’ but it doesn’t mean ‘unhealthy’ either. If you take a look at the epidemics that originated from non-organic foods you will find that factory-farming is not too healthy either. Surely the argument must be for rigorous standards and fair prices to counter the activities of mass-producers, not labelling organic foods in a way that implies they are unhealthy. It’s not the foods – it’s the way that they are grown and transported that makes for danger.

  3. Johnman says:

    Here is another viewpoint, highlighting that it’s not sprouts that are unhealthy nor is it organic that’s unhealthy. It’s ignorance and malpractice in any form of food production that’s unhealthy:


Comment on this post

Log in or register to post a comment.

  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • name on Who is the enemy?: Simply stating it is correct doesn't make it so, I just wish you would apply the same epistemic vigilance to "Muslim crimes" as you do to their Hebrew...
    • Glen Newey on Unwinnable War: The legal issue admits of far less clarity than the simple terms in which you – I imagine quite sincerely – frame them. For the benefit of readers...
    • Geoff Roberts on The New Normal: The causes go back a long way into the colonial past, but the more immediate causes stem from the activities of the US forces in the name of freedom a...
    • sol_adelman on The New Normal: There's also the fact that the French state denied the mass drownings of '61 even happened for forty-odd years. No episode in post-war W European hist...
    • funky gibbon on At Wembley: If England get France in the quarter finals of Euro 16 I expect that a good deal of the fraternity will go out the window

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

  • From the LRB Archive

    Stephen W. Smith:
    The French Intervention in Mali
    7 February 2013

    ‘Depending on what counts as military intervention, France changed the course of history by force in sub-Saharan Africa about thirty times between 1945 and 1990.’

    Bruce Whitehouse:
    What went wrong in Mali?
    30 August 2012

    ‘The Republic of Mali has long been seen as the exception to the dictatorships or civil wars that have seemed the rule in West Africa since the end of the Cold War.’

    Jeremy Harding: Algeria’s Camus
    4 December 2014

    ‘Camus liked to hector the settlers, whose behaviour reflected the structural injustices of colonialism. All the same, he felt that certain misconceptions in metropolitan France needed straightening out.’

    Hugh Roberts: The Hijackers
    16 July 2015

    ‘American intelligence saw Islamic State coming and was not only relaxed about the prospect but, it appears, positively interested in it.’

Advertisement Advertisement