What can be done

P.F. Strawson, 18 February 1982

In earlier essays, not reproduced in this volume, Quine wrote, ‘Philosophy, or what appeals to me under that head, is continuous with science’; and, more bluntly: ‘Philosophy of...

Read more about What can be done

Deciding Derrida

David Hoy, 18 February 1982

Of the essays collected and excellently translated in Dissemination, the best example of Derrida’s own practice of the deconstructive criticism he fathered is ‘Plato’s...

Read more about Deciding Derrida

Poetry and Christianity

Barbara Everett, 4 February 1982

‘Water-Music’ makes in itself a fine concept, through the delicate difference of its components, water being transparent though sometimes audible, music being always audible and...

Read more about Poetry and Christianity

Imbroglio

Douglas Johnson, 4 February 1982

On Wednesday, 23 December 1981, four men were sent to prison for the murder, on 24 December 1976, of the Prince de Broglie. The trial, in the Paris assize court, ended with Gérard...

Read more about Imbroglio

Jews’ Harps

Gabriel Josipovici, 4 February 1982

It is not often that a reviewer can say that the book under review has altered his entire conception of the past. Yet that is what I have to say about this book. It is, to begin with, the product...

Read more about Jews’ Harps

Past, Present and Future

A.J. Ayer, 21 January 1982

These three volumes of Professor Anscombe’s collected papers encompass everything of importance that she has published, apart from her work as literary executor and translator of Ludwig...

Read more about Past, Present and Future

Both this and the following statement are false. Douglas Hofstadter and Daniel Dennett’s book is well worth £9.95. One does not have to be a philosopher to realise that I have already...

Read more about What is Mind? No Matter. What is Matter? Never Mind

The Will and the Body

David Pears, 17 December 1981

In the last twenty-five years there has been increasing interest in the philosophy of action, and many different theories have been put forward. The revival of this subject had several causes. If...

Read more about The Will and the Body

Ideal Speech

Geoffrey Hawthorn, 19 November 1981

Natural man is born free but is everywhere in chains. ‘Civilised man’, unfortunately, ‘is born and dies a slave. The infant is bound up in swaddling clothes, the corpse is...

Read more about Ideal Speech

Wittgenstein’s Confessions

Norman Malcolm, 19 November 1981

Rush Rhees has put together a wonderful book. These Recollections are a rich portrayal of Wittgenstein’s extraordinary character and personality, moral force, stunning intelligence. The...

Read more about Wittgenstein’s Confessions

Ancient and Modern

M.A. Screech, 19 November 1981

Does Luther explain Hitler? Oberman, an international Dutchman at home in Tuebingen, asks the question only to toss it aside: the Reformation was not a ‘German tragedy’. Into this...

Read more about Ancient and Modern

Vico and Berlin

Hans Aarsleff, 5 November 1981

Sir Isaiah Berlin’s wide range of interests and achievements illustrates the pluralism he admires: music critic, philosopher, writer, professor, civil servant, administrator, college...

Read more about Vico and Berlin

Professor Aarsleff kindly sent me a copy of his article before publication; his courtesy enables me to provide an immediate rejoinder. I read it with mounting astonishment. Since I know Professor...

Read more about Isaiah Berlin responds to the foregoing criticisms of his work

Foetus Rights

Onora O’Neill, 5 November 1981

Twenty years ago abortion was illegal in most countries and nearly always hazardous: today it is legal in most developed countries and a routine medical procedure. It is hard to think of another...

Read more about Foetus Rights

De-Nazification

Noël Annan, 15 October 1981

Investigative journalism has many triumphs to its credit. It toppled a President of the United States. It has exposed, through the hard leg-work of tiny teams of sleuths, the evasions of...

Read more about De-Nazification

Cause and Effect

A.J. Ayer, 15 October 1981

On the flyleaf of Messrs Beauchamp and Rosenberg’s book about Hume’s theory of causation, Professor Donald Davidson says of it: ‘This is certainly the best available discussion...

Read more about Cause and Effect

Existence Unperceived

W.D. Hart, 15 October 1981

Professor Sir Peter Strawson is properly honoured by the 12 essays written for this anthology. Unlike the papers in some other collections of this kind, most of these are addressed to issues in...

Read more about Existence Unperceived

Onward Muslim Soldiers

Malise Ruthven, 1 October 1981

Fourteen centuries ago the Prophet Muhammad united the tribes of Arabia under the banner of Islam and reconquered for the One True God the Holy City of Mecca which had long been a centre of...

Read more about Onward Muslim Soldiers