Skinned alive

John Bayley

  • Collected Poems by George Barker, edited by Robert Fraser
    Faber, 838 pp, £27.50, May 1987, ISBN 0 571 13972 8
  • By Grand Central Station I sat down and wept by Elizabeth Smart, introduction by Brigid Brophy
    Grafton, 126 pp, £2.50, July 1987, ISBN 0 586 02083 7

Amusing, and perhaps instructive, to think of great paintings whose voyage into mystery and meaning seems to depend, in the first instance, on a technical trick: a separation of planes so that the head of the principal figure lives in a different world from that of the body, and the rest of the picture. Rembrandt’s ‘Polish Rider’ travels serenely on a pantomime horse, deftly accoutred with his bowcase, his shapka, his shapely uniform of red and white. But the face is that of a beautiful woman, smiling quietly in some secret satisfaction, disembodied from the soldier’s quest. Botticelli’s Venus is a Peruginesque Madonna with no clothes, posed on a pagan shell. The formidable eyeballs of Piero’s risen Christ, separated from the cornea in their upward gaze, forbid any offering from the spectator of devotion or reciprocity. The smile of Leonardo’s famous portrait is wholly hermaphroditic. Most striking of all, the upside-down face of Marsyas, in his agony at the surgeon’s hands of scientific Apollo, expresses a refined and sexless being lost on the solitary verge of pleasure, while Midas-Titian gazes tearfully not at him but at some other terror.

The full text of this book review is only available to subscribers of the London Review of Books.

You are not logged in