« | Home | »

Lights, Camera, Justice!

Tags:

The United States Supreme Court does not permit video recording. ‘The day you see a camera come into our courtroom,’ Justice David Souter said in 1996, ‘it’s going to roll over my dead body.’ The Supreme Court is not, he argued, ‘part of the entertainment industry’.

In a recent paper called Transforming Our Justice System, the United Kingdom’s Ministry of Justice says that the justice system ‘should be competing … with every modern consumer experience’ that citizens ‘have in their lives’. Our institutions of justice are increasingly conflated with consumer products. Many court fees are set at a for-profit level, the idea being courts provide a valuable service and consumers should pay for it. The legal industry is assessed in terms of (and reformed with an eye on) the revenue it generates. Court buildings are no exception. The Supreme Court, for example, is available for private hire: a scene in Bridget Jones’s Baby was filmed there. A spokesperson explained that this was ‘part of a wider programme of generating income to ease pressure on the public purse’.

Supreme Court oral arguments are filmed and made available online; there are summaries of judgments on YouTube. Their contribution to the entertainment industry is, so far, unremarkable: only five of the Court’s YouTube clips have more than 10,000 views.

Comments

  1. HBART says:

    Sooner or later television will convert the courts to television just as it has converted everything else it “covers” to television.


  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • Trish Gellam on Why We Strike: At the University of Reading there was a vote of no confidence in Vice Chancellor David Bell backed by almost 90% of the staff. He refused to resign. ...
    • XopherO on Why We Strike: I seem to remember that the original decline in what was a very healthy pension fund was originally caused, not by the increased longevity of academic...
    • Anaximander on Something to Look Forward To?: Western capitalism has until now relied on the labourers having sufficient income to buy (some of) what they make. That's now changing. The rentier...
    • Graucho on The Seine Also Rises: When water get warmer it evaporates more. When air gets warmer it holds more moisture. Western Europe is downwind of a very large pond. Global wetting...
    • Gardiner Linda on The Seine Also Rises: A film from 2007, 'Musée haut, musée bas' (based on a play of the same name from 2004), envisages just this scenario. Set in an imaginary cross betw...

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

Advertisement Advertisement