« | Home | »

More Effective than Airstrikes

Tags: | |

A few years ago, an Israeli F16 fighter pilot I know went on a training exercise for a possible attack on Iran’s nuclear reactors. When he got back I asked him if such an operation could actually succeed. He said he thought Israel had the capacity to carry it out, but the military leadership was against it. When I asked him why, he explained that even if an airstrike were completely successful, the Iranians would be able to rebuild their reactors within two years. The operation, he said, would only work if sanctions were intensified immediately after the attack, and most sanctioning countries would be unlikely to agree to that. He concluded by pointing out that Iran would probably retaliate against Israel, and ‘while it is easy to get into such a bloody game, it is completely unclear how to get out.’

The recent deal – assuming it’s approved by US and Iranian legislators – will accomplish more than the Israeli military would have been able to. Rather than two years, Tehran’s nuclear development will be stalled for a decade or more, and a new front with Iran has been taken off the table. This is probably the reason most IDF generals are uncharacteristically reticent about the agreement: they know it is advantageous but are afraid of upsetting the Israeli prime minister, Binyamin Netanyahu, and his supporters in the United States.

Comments

  1. Sharoni says:

    Any currently serving IDF genearls are reticent because they’re soldiers, not elected politicians and not supposed to and do not comment on political decisions or critize the elected government. They are not being uncharacteristically recticent.

    • akvartany says:

      Generals, security experts of a democratic country do and have the right to air their opinions and not follow orders when a fanatic is running the country. Only wish Hitlers generals had guts to do so as the Israeli one’s have done. many lives may have been saved.


  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • steve kay on Where the Wild Things Weren’t: The Grauniad on line has pictures of David Cameron at this very festival. Why does your collection of images not include LRB team members beating him ...
    • Kathryn Dunathan on When the Fire Comes: There is a land registry, but it is incomplete, way behind schedule in meeting the requirements of the EU to provide a modern land registry that is us...
    • Joe Morison on In the Hall of Mirrors: I’d be interested to know how Russia, with the severe economic sanctions in place against it, will be effected by the trade wars that Trump is start...
    • Jeremy Bernstein on Four-Dimensional Proust: I an surprised that none of my sophisticated commentators mentioned Durrell's Alexandria Quartet. Durrell claims to have been inspired by relativity a...
    • Camus on At the Luzhniki Stadium: Not often that I get the chance to tell this story. I was in Wembley Stadium on the day that England actually won the World Cup - not only that, I la...

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

Advertisement
Advertisement