« | Home | »

Untenurable

Tags: |

Bar-Ilan University near Tel Aviv claims to be the largest university in Israel. Its official goal is to cultivate and combine ‘Jewish identity and tradition with modern technologies and research’. Fifteen years ago, after Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated by one of its students, the university set out to temper its right-wing tendencies and become a more liberal institution guided by ostensibly neutral professional procedures and regulations. Bar-Ilan may have continued to provide accreditation for two colleges in illegal West Bank settlements, but it also developed an excellent gender studies programme and hired a number of left-wing academics.

One of them was Ariella Azoulay, who teaches visual culture and contemporary philosophy. Over the past decade she has become one of Israel’s foremost cultural theorists, producing dozens of journal articles, book chapters and translations, curating a number of exhibitions, and writing several books. She has been published by such presses as MIT, Zone, Verso and Stanford. She is also the supervisor of more than ten PhD students. Just the kind of academic, in other words, that universities want on their staff.

Yet Bar-Ilan recently denied Azoulay’s bid for tenure, effectively firing her. The reasons for the decision have not been made public, but it should baffle anyone familiar with academic promotion procedures who looks at Azoulay’s CV. There is, however, another fact to be taken into account: Azoulay’s prominent political activism. One of the exhibitions she curated, for example, Act of State, included hundreds of photographs exposing the realities of four decades of occupation. The show was held at a gallery in the centre of Tel Aviv. A significant part of Azoulay’s work is critical of Israel’s human rights abuses and of Zionism. So much for the liberal idea of a neutral professional process. Bar-Ilan, it seems, could not stomach giving tenure to a vocal Zionist apostate.

Comments on “Untenurable”

  1. pinhut says:

    I found this post interesting, but I do have a query about this:

    “So much for the liberal idea of a neutral professional process.”

    Is it really a specifically liberal idea to have a neutral process? I have never heard that view before.

  2. richie says:

    This is typical Neve Gordon bullfeathers. Not only does Azoulay not have a single academic publication to her name, but her entire “academic” record consists of collecting photographs tendentiously strung together to form political proaganda. Had she not been the wife of leftwing extremist Prof. Adi Ophir, she would never have been hired at all at any school in Israel. Of course, Neve Gordon’s own “academic” record consists of nothing but political proaganda and demononization of Israel misrepresented as “research,” so we can see why he should feel so passionately about Azoulay’s career!

  3. Alan says:

    Talking of being neutral, I find it disturbing that the author of this article didn’t disclose the fact that he works for a competitor of Bar-Ilan – he works for Ben-Gurion University.

    Furthermore, saying she was ‘effectively fired’ is sensationalism and a gross exaggeration – she was denied tenure – ‘effectively denied promotion’ would be a better description.

    Disclosure: I sometimes do contract work for Bar-Ilan, although I have no personal or professional stake in this matter.

Comment on this post

Log in or register to post a comment.


  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • Harry Stopes on Trump, #takeaknee and American History: The response to James McClean, a West Brom player from Derry who refuses to wear the poppy on his shirt during October/ November (like the parading of...
    • Thomas Jones on Glen Newey 1961-2017: A message from Glen Newey's family: We are asking for contributions from Glen’s friends, colleagues and students around the world in the hope of ...
    • shosha shuldeiner on The Conventional Mr Hefner: I think the answer to your query as to why has the adjective 'conventional' been attached to Mr. Hefner's description, lies in the the observation of ...
    • Jeremy Bernstein on The Conventional Mr Hefner: I had one encounter with Playboy. I had written a profile of Stanley Kubrick for the New Yorker that centered on chess. I was visiting Oxford and was ...
    • RobotBoy on ‘This Bankrupt Island’: Around five million Puerto Ricans (and those of PR descent) live on the U.S. mainland - more than on the island. There are over 700,000 Puerto Ricans ...

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

Advertisement Advertisement