« | Home | »

In a Villanelle Mood

Tags: |

In a villanelle mood, Colm Tóibín started the following poem. The immediate context was a remark by a colleague that our students (and indeed most of our colleagues) don’t seem to get excited about theory the way they used to. The title and first stanza are Colm’s, and therefore so are the rhymes. You can tell from the word ‘skid’ that I’m running out of options.

A Structuralist Lament

They don’t thrill at the sign as we once did.
They see Saussure as one more dead white male
Trapped between the ego and the id.

The Elementary Structures all are hid,
No Lévi-Strauss is heard to tell the tale:
They don’t thrill at the sign as we once did.

Semiotics had its day but flipped its lid,
Got lost inside the advertising whale,
Or trapped between the ego and the id.

Alas, poor Barthes, who cares for Ess and Zed?
When every morpheme’s up for sale
They don’t thrill at the sign as we once did.

And as for ‘Theory’ writ large, heaven forbid,
There’s nothing left but cakes and ale
Trapped between the ego and the id.

Myth and symbol slide and skid,
It’s lost for good, the fine old trail.
They don’t thrill at the sign as we once did,
Trapped as we were between the ego and the id.

Comments on “In a Villanelle Mood”

  1. Martin says:

    Well, sadly, it’s a sign of the times.

Comment on this post

Log in or register to post a comment.


  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • Bob Beck on Beware of Cows: There was a strikingly similar, and farcical, incident in Ottawa in Oct. 2014. A disturbed young man, armed with an anitique rifle -- the kind of thin...
    • jcl on Raw Material: We did not need a debate about (nonexistent) censorship - We need a conversation about what kinds of acts are effective for becoming an accomplice in ...
    • IPFreely on Blunt Instruments: "They have to pay for their crimes... " has been the clarion call of the right ever since the days of public hanging and flogging. Why not send some...
    • Glen Newey on Beware of Cows: I could have made the following points more explicitly, but generally credit LRB readers with the intelligence to join up the dots. Coverage of thi...
    • Parissing on Raw Material: My European vantage must have spoiled me. From appeals to an unquestionable moral authority and the various congregational amens known as virtue signa...

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

Advertisement Advertisement