« | Home | »

Keep Off the Sprouts


‘It’s the sprouts,’ the head of the federal Robert Koch Institute in Berlin, Reinhard Burger, announced on 10 June. No surprise. Bean-sprout food-poisoning outbreaks occur regularly. The first big one was caused by Salmonella in the UK in 1988, when 143 people fell ill after eating contaminated mung bean sprouts. The outbreak in Sakai City in Japan in 1996 was caused by radish sprouts contaminated with E.coli O157. In the UK last year 231 people were infected with Salmonella from bean sprouts.

The majority of bean-sprout outbreak victims are women, probably because children and men are less likely to eat them. The outbreak can have been running for a while before it’s noticed. Investigations are often started only when there are an unusual number of cases caused by a rare strain of microbe. And in the majority of outbreaks the bacteria are not found on the suspect sprouts. The German outbreak has all these features. But there’s strong evidence that incriminates the sprouts as the vector for E.coli O104. A study of travel groups and club members who had eaten at a restaurant was crucial. Menus, receipts, information about ingredients and photographs showing food on plates were compared to identify what the sick had eaten but the well hadn’t. There is also a geographical relationship between case clusters and the distribution chain of sprouts from the producer in Lower Saxony.

Raw bean sprouts are a high-risk food because beans can have invisible contamination on them, and because the conditions used for sprouting – many hours in the warmth and wet – are optimal for the growth of bacteria. The only possible ways to reduce the risk are to use beans from a trustworthy grower who doesn’t get manure on his harvest, and decontamination. The best chemical decontaminant is bleach, but the highest permitted concentration won’t kill all the bugs. The only process that looks promising is irradiation. It’s hard to see organic sprouters going down this route.

Comments on “Keep Off the Sprouts”

  1. nechaev says:

    “The only process that looks promising is irradiation”

    oddly enough this seems to be the exact same argument made by the Wall Street Journal columnist this weekend [“Europe’s Organic Food Scare”].
    and of course inquiring minds might well ask: cui bono on that one….
    no doubt some mighty big profits to be made in large-scale food irradiation were that to become the latest hysteria-triggered fashion

    as a sprout eater of many decades standing may i suggest that the most promising solution is actually just some common sense. Sprout them yourself, or – with mung beans buy them prefab if you must but then cook them, slowly, over a low heat. And in the summer avoid the salad bar offerings of alfafa shoots, etc. (do we know if those sickened in Germany were made ill by sprouts they had bought in shops, or was it entirely via restaurant salad bars? These are generally great places to spread disease in the summer months…)

    I’m rather suspicious of any rush-to-irradiation. I see a lot of fruits imported from different lands in the supermarkets, and assume some of it has been irradiated. Namely the box of kiwis I bought in the beginning of March, hard as stones, which remain sitting here in the open at mid-June and are still far from ripe. Or those mangoes which never ripen but eventually just turn brown. I don’t think that the wise men of science really know much about what happens to the nutritional value of food following radiation.

  2. klhoughton says:

    Uh, no. The sprouts carried the E. coli (which, apparently, Mr. Pennington does not know can only be originated by animals, not plants–or more likely, he does and is just being disingenuous to readers in referring to the sprouts as “the vector” and hoping people will confuse that with “root cause”), but they are NOT the source of it.

    That would be the animal offal (can’t use the colloquial word [sh*t] on the LRB blog) that was use to fertilize the sprouts.

    Irradiation isn’t the cure; not using unprocessed animal droppings as fertilizer is.

    Which, not coincidentally, would ameliorate nechaev’s worries as well.

    It’s sad to see the LRB try to pass off such “analysis.” When did you become News of the World?

    • Thomas Jones says:

      1. Who would think ‘vector’ meant ‘root cause’? Perhaps someone who thinks that ‘offal’ means ‘shit’.

      2. Pennington makes it plain that animal shit (you can use the word all you like; we’re not the News of the World) is where the bacteria get onto the beans from. Both here – ‘The only possible ways to reduce the risk are to use beans from a trustworthy grower who doesn’t get manure on his harvest…’ – and in his previous post on the subject: ‘E. coli evolves in real time, by taking up DNA from its brothers and sisters as they huddle together in the bowels of their hosts. We may never know where O104 has come from, though we will probably find out quite soon where it lives in nature. Sampling cowpats is straightforward, at least.’

  3. autodial says:

    A bit of ordure perhaps….

Comment on this post

Log in or register to post a comment.

  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • name on Who is the enemy?: Simply stating it is correct doesn't make it so, I just wish you would apply the same epistemic vigilance to "Muslim crimes" as you do to their Hebrew...
    • Glen Newey on Unwinnable War: The legal issue admits of far less clarity than the simple terms in which you – I imagine quite sincerely – frame them. For the benefit of readers...
    • Geoff Roberts on The New Normal: The causes go back a long way into the colonial past, but the more immediate causes stem from the activities of the US forces in the name of freedom a...
    • sol_adelman on The New Normal: There's also the fact that the French state denied the mass drownings of '61 even happened for forty-odd years. No episode in post-war W European hist...
    • funky gibbon on At Wembley: If England get France in the quarter finals of Euro 16 I expect that a good deal of the fraternity will go out the window

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

  • From the LRB Archive

    Edward Said: The Iraq War
    17 April 2003

    ‘This is the most reckless war in modern times. It is all about imperial arrogance unschooled in worldliness, unfettered either by competence or experience, undeterred by history or human complexity, unrepentant in its violence and the cruelty of its technology.’

    David Runciman:
    The Politics of Good Intentions
    8 May 2003

    ‘One of the things that unites all critics of Blair’s war in Iraq, whether from the Left or the Right, is that they are sick of the sound of Blair trumpeting the purity of his purpose, when what matters is the consequences of his actions.’

    Simon Wren-Lewis: The Austerity Con
    19 February 2015

    ‘How did a policy that makes so little sense to economists come to be seen by so many people as inevitable?’

    Hugh Roberts: The Hijackers
    16 July 2015

    ‘American intelligence saw Islamic State coming and was not only relaxed about the prospect but, it appears, positively interested in it.’

Advertisement Advertisement