« | Home | »

No Right of Return

Tags: | |

Imagine you were a Palestinian teenager, born in Jerusalem, when the Israelis took charge of your city in 1967. Imagine you received an ID card, giving you the right to residence in the place of your birth. That permit was in order when you left in the 1970s to study in the US. When you returned 20 years later, having graduated, married and started a family, you presented your document at the airport, only to be told it had been revoked.

This is the story of Munther Fahmi, who went back to Jerusalem after the signing of the Oslo Accords, and founded the bookshop at the American Colony Hotel. Fahmi was never a ‘citizen’ under occupation. But now he couldn’t even remain a resident: he had to become a sightseer, entering on a US passport with a tourist visa. Which is how he’s been coming and going, renewing the visa, for years. According to his lawyer, Fahmi was badly misled: his resident’s permit was valid when he moved back to Jerusalem in the 1990s. Never mind that: now he’s been told he’ll have to go.  

Eland, the travel publisher, describes Munther’s shop as ‘having the best selection of literature in the Middle East’. A petition to the Ministry of the Interior is gathering signatures.

Comments on “No Right of Return”

  1. Userdafi says:

    Imagine you were a Jewish teenager, born in Yemen, when anti-Jewish riots swept the country forcing you to seek refuge in Israel (1949-50).

    Imagine you were a Jewish teenager, born in Iraq, when anti-Jewish violence swept the country forcing you to seek refuge in Israel (1950-52).

    Imagine you were a Jewish-Egyptian teenager kicked out from Egypt in 1956.

    Imagine you were a Jewish ‘Pied-Noir’ teenager kicked out from Algeria in 1962

    Imagine you were a Jewish teenager kicked out from Iran.

    Imagine you were a Jewish teenager, born in Morocco or Libya or Syria or Lebanon or Bahrain or Aden or Djibouti…

    Imagine losing everything.. your house, comfort, belongings, friends, community, neighborhood, language, culture, hope, and ultimately the life you once knew.

    Imagine being deprived of the right to reside in the place of your birth.

    Imagine losing everything and never being able to come back not even as a sightseer, entering the land of your fathers on a foreign passport with a tourist visa.

    This is the story of millions of Israelis.

    Israel is a sovereign country and has the right to decide who can enter and stay on its territory.

    “Peace can only be achieved through understanding” and compromise.

    The past is gone.

    There is no ‘right’ of return. Period.

    Ciao Ciao

Comment on this post

Log in or register to post a comment.


  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • UncleShoutingSmut on Goodbye, Circumflex: Unfortunately this post is likely to leave readers with a very partial idea of what is going on. Firstly, there is no "edict": all that has happened i...
    • martyn94 on The Price of Everything: If it's a joke at anyone's expense, it's surely at the expense of any super-rich who take it seriously. I used to skim it occasionally as a diversion ...
    • mideastzebra on Swedish-Israeli Tensions: Avigdor Liberman was not foreign minister November 2015.
    • lars hakanson on Exit Cameron: Europe will for good reason rejoice when the UK elects to leave. The country has over the years provided nothing but obstacles to European integration...
    • Michael Schuller on Immigration Scandals: The Home Office is keen to be seen to be acting tough on immigration, although I'm not sure that the wider project has anything to do with real number...

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

  • From the LRB Archive

    Chris Lehmann: The Candidates
    18 June 2015

    ‘Every one of the Republican candidates can be described as a full-blown adult failure. These are people who, in most cases, have been granted virtually every imaginable advantage on the road to success, and managed nevertheless to foul things up along the way.’

    Hugh Pennington:
    The Problem with Biodiversity
    10 May 2007

    ‘As a medical microbiologist, for example, I have spent my career fighting biodiversity: my ultimate aim has been to cause the extinction of harmful microbes, an objective shared by veterinary and plant pathologists. But despite more than a hundred years of concentrated effort, supported by solid science, smallpox has been the only success.’

    Jeremy Harding: At the Mexican Border
    20 October 2011

    ‘The battle against illegal migration is a domestic version of America’s interventions overseas, with many of the same trappings: big manpower commitments, militarisation, pursuit, detection, rendition, loss of life. The Mexican border was already the focus of attention before 9/11; it is now a fixation that shows no signs of abating.’

    James Meek: When the Floods Came
    31 July 2008

    ‘Last July, a few days after the floods arrived, with 350,000 people still cut off from the first necessity of life, Severn Trent held its annual general meeting. It announced profits of £325 million, and confirmed a dividend for shareholders of £143 million. Not long afterwards the company, with the consent of the water regulator Ofwat, announced that it wouldn’t be compensating customers: all would be charged as if they had had running water, even when they hadn’t.’

Advertisement Advertisement