« | Home | »

The Death of Fadlallah

Tags: |

Misperception, willful or naive, is to be expected in US commentary on the Middle East. But it’s hard to think of an Arab figure as consistently misperceived as the Lebanese Shia cleric Mohammad Hussein Fadlallah, who died on 4 July (a holiday you can be fairly sure he wasn’t celebrating). In obituaries in the American press (and in poor Octavia Nasr’s tweet, which cost her a job at CNN), Fadlallah was, as ever, described as the ‘spiritual leader’ or ‘spiritual father’ of Hezbollah: never mind that he’d been estranged from Hezbollah since the 1990s. And he was invariably portrayed as a dangerous extremist, if not a terrorist. You would hardly know that he was the first cleric in the Islamic world to denounce the attacks of September 11, or that he was an advocate of gender equality and inter-religious dialogue, staking out positions which won him the praise of Frances Guy, Britain’s ambassador to Beirut. Guy may be joining Nasr on the unemployment line for cutting through the usual clichés about Hezbollah’s ‘spiritual leader’: her blog, honouring Fadlallah as a ‘decent man’ whose death left Lebanon ‘a lesser place’, was taken down by the Foreign Office after ‘mature consideration’ — and vituperative Israeli attacks. This article by David Kenner in Foreign Policy sets the record straight on a complicated and influential man.

Comments on “The Death of Fadlallah”

  1. pinhut says:

    I read the Independent piece on it. Once you reached the line – “The Israel reaction was one of fury…” then you knew it was all over for Guy. Thou shalt not offendeth Israel has become a rather central, if unstated, feature of UK politics since 1997.

    Israel is also currently staging a Holocaust memorial in Guatemala, a country whose ‘dirty war’ it supplied equipment to (after the US imposed a military embargo), including a computer system that was used to target subversives for disappearance, along with the services of COIN advisers, etc.

    That was state terrorism, though, so I suppose it’s okay.

  2. Desertico says:

    This is a well written piece on this man about who I had read very little and heard even less. The questions must inevitably arise as to who is going to replace Fadlallah.

Comment on this post

Log in or register to post a comment.

  • Recent Posts

    RSS – posts

  • Contributors

  • Recent Comments

    • Jeremy Bernstein on How to Rig an Election: As a physicist who has followed closely nuclear arms proliferation I have noted and commented on in print on Trump's willful ignorance of the subject...
    • ghosted on Buhari Loses the Plot: Buhari seemed like a good man, and still seems it, although certainly a man from another age who is struggling to make sense of how things have change...
    • semitone on How to Rig an Election: One frustration with following the current election is the paucity of polling on Congressional seats. The presidency is surely all but in the bag; the...
    • michael bosley on British Hospitality: This isn't a difficult or complex issue. And the Davies man is my MP, for Chrissakes'. Western values - huh, yeah - what are they good for?
    • jrsm on On the Government’s Lists: If you want a sad preview of the future of your immigration system, have a look at the horrors we now enforce in Australia: offshore torture camps for...

    RSS – comments

  • Contact

  • Blog Archive

Advertisement Advertisement